TAU study finds widespread misinterpretation of gene expression data

Written on |

Bias can be now be removed from data to filter out false results, researchers say

Reproducibility of research data is a major challenge in experimental biology. As data generated by genomic-scale techniques increases in complexity, this concern is becoming more and more worrisome.

RNA-seq, one of the most widely used methods in modern molecular biology, allows in a single test the simultaneous measurement of the expression level of all genes in a given sample. New research by a Tel Aviv University group identifies a frequent technical bias in data generated by RNA-seq technology, which often leads to false results.

The study was conducted by Dr. Shir Mandelbaum, Dr. Zohar Manber, Dr. Orna Elroy-Stein and Dr. Ran Elkon at TAU’s Sackler Faculty of Medicine and George S. Wise Faculty of Life Sciences and was published on November 12 in PLOS Biology.

“Recent years have witnessed a growing alarm about false results in biological research, sometimes referred to as the reproducibility crisis,” Dr. Elkon, lead author of the study, says. “This study emphasizes the importance of proper statistical handling of data to lessen the number of misleading findings.”

Removing bias from science

A main goal of RNA-seq experiments is to characterize biological processes that are activated or repressed in response to different conditions.

The researchers analyzed dozens of publicly available RNA-seq datasets to profile the cellular responses to numerous stresses. During the research, the scientists noticed that sets of particularly short or long genes repeatedly showed changes in the expression level measured by the apparent number of RNA transcripts from a given gene. Puzzled by this recurring pattern, the team wondered whether it reflected some universal biological response common to different triggers or whether it stemmed from some experimental condition.

To tackle this question, they compared replicated samples from the same biological condition. Differences in gene expression between replicates can reflect technical effects that are not related to the experiment’s biological factor of interest. Unexpectedly, the same pattern of particularly short or long genes showing changes in expression level was observed in these comparisons between replicates. This pattern is the result of a technical bias that seemed to be coupled with gene length, the researchers say.

Importantly, the TAU researchers were able to show how the length bias they detected in many RNA-seq datasets led to the false identification of specific biological functions as cellular responses to the conditions tested. “Such misinterpretation of the data could lead to completely misleading conclusions,” Dr. Elkon concludes. “In practical terms, the study also shows how this bias can be removed from the data, thus filtering out false results while preserving the biologically relevant ones.”

related posts

Recruiting ‘Fighting Cells’ to Destroy Tumors

September 14, 2021

TAU Team Reverses Early Signs of Alzheimer’s

September 10, 2021

Nicotine Testing of Children Curbs Parents’ Smoking

September 5, 2021

The Silent Prophets

August 31, 2021

Want to Fall in Love? Step Outside in The Sun

August 30, 2021

First 3D-bioprinting of entire active tumor

August 18, 2021

New Warning Sign for Breast Cancer

August 6, 2021

COVID-19 Immunity Varies Among Genders and Age Groups

July 25, 2021

New study found differences between women and men in the level of COVID-19 antibodies

July 15, 2021

A world first: Technology that restores the sense of touch in nerves damaged as a result of amputation or injury

July 15, 2021

New nanotech from TAU produces “healthy” electric current from the human body itself

July 9, 2021

Want to Live a Long Life? Consider Investing in Your Marriage.

July 2, 2021

A world first: Targeted delivery of therapeutic RNAs only to cancer cells, with no harm caused to healthy cells

June 30, 2021

Combating Antibiotic Resistance

June 22, 2021

Diamonds in the Rough

June 3, 2021

How Will We Brave the Post-COVID Era?

May 31, 2021

Are We Getting to the Root of Cancer?

May 3, 2021

Optical Technology Generates Immediate Melanoma Diagnosis

April 27, 2021

Gut Healing

April 25, 2021

Could Your Smartphone Be Damaging Your Teeth?

April 4, 2021

The Quest for A Lifesaving Cure

March 16, 2021

A Healthier Alternative to Antibiotics

February 24, 2021

Children with Autism during Lockdown: Serious Implications for Behavior and Development

February 22, 2021

Cancer Breakthrough: Cells’ Uniqueness is Also Weakness

January 29, 2021

TAU Scientists Develop Innovative Therapy to Prevent Deafness

December 28, 2020

Two TAU Professors Win 2020 Nature Mentoring Award

December 28, 2020

Lack of Teacher Support during Pandemic Causes Acute Emotional Harm

December 4, 2020

New Discovery: Development of the Inner Ear in Embryos is Similar to Crystal Formation

November 26, 2020

In First, Aging Stopped in Humans: TAU Co-Study

November 23, 2020

TAU developed genome editing system destroys cancer cells

November 20, 2020

TAU Co-Study: “Green Revolution” Decreased Infant Mortality

November 17, 2020

Study: Women Suffer More from COVID-related Orofacial Pain

November 12, 2020

Global First: Center for Combating Pandemics

October 22, 2020

TAU Researchers Discover Antibody Combo that Fights COVID-19

October 12, 2020

Researchers Identified the Genetic Causes of Inherited Hearing Loss in the Jewish Population of Israel

September 30, 2020

Targeting Melanoma

September 9, 2020

TAU Inaugurates Shmunis School of Biomedicine and Cancer Research

September 8, 2020

Physical exercise can help improve both physical and mental health

August 31, 2020

New school for Biomedicine and Cancer Research at Tel Aviv University

August 13, 2020

An Experimental Drug for Alzheimer’s May Help Children with Autism

August 5, 2020

TAU Study: Stimulating Immune System Prevents Post-Surgery Metastasis

July 27, 2020

TAU Researcher Fights Epidemics Both Viral and Virtual

July 23, 2020

TAU study: Oxygen therapy improves cognitive function in seniors

July 16, 2020

TAU-led Team Destroys Cancer Cells with Ultrasound

July 9, 2020

New nanomedicines for mRNA therapeutics in breast cancer and heart failure

July 6, 2020

3D printed heart used to test life-saving drugs

June 29, 2020

Did climate change cause infections 6,000 years ago?

May 21, 2020

Accurate 3D imaging could significantly improve IVF treatments

May 18, 2020

Fibroblasts involved in healing spur tumor growth in cancer

December 23, 2019

Eating in sync with biological clock could replace diabetes treatment

December 15, 2019
Ontario and Western Canada

3130 Bathurst Street, Suite, 214, Toronto, ON | M6A 2A1 
Phone: 416.787.9930 | Toll Free: 833.32.CFTAU (22328)
Email: toronto@cftau.ca

Ottawa, Quebec and Atlantic Canada

6900 Boulevard Décarie, Suite 3480, Montreal, QC | H3X 2T8
Phone: 514.344.3417
Email: montreal@cftau.ca


© CFTAU  | all rights reserved
Charitable registration: 124035643RR0001

TO TOP